Manure Rules not just for Large CAFOs

Manure Rules not just for Large CAFOs

Listen to a discussion of the content in this article on this episode of the BeefWatch podcast. You can subscribe to new episodes in iTunes or paste http://feeds.feedburner.com/unlbeefwatch into your podcast app.

Subscribe to BeefWatch

Have you ever been overwhelmed by the amount of manure regulations in Nebraska? Or anywhere? Let’s make it a little easier to digest.

Take Home Message:   
The ultimate purpose of all manure regulations is to keep water free from contamination.

The good news is that Nebraska regulations related to manure do not change very often. In fact, the current regulations have been in effect since October 2011. So everyone can better follow the rules, let’s break it down into something that is a little easier to follow.

Manure 101

  1. Manure regulations can be found in Title 130, Livestock Waste Control Regulations. A condensed manure version is also available. The regulations stem from the Clean Water Act, which is enforced by the US EPA, the ultimate regulating authority on manure.
  2. The primary regulatory authority in Nebraska is the Department of Environment and Energy.
  3. Livestock operations (also known as AFOs) are defined by the number of animals as small, medium or large, which determines which rules apply.
  4. The ultimate purpose of all manure regulations is to keep water free from contamination (i.e. nutrients or pathogens).

Requirements vs Recommendations

All AFOs, regardless of size, have manure regulations. Permitted operations, however, have more requirements than operations that are not required to obtain a permit. The following table provides an overview:

 

Permitted Livestock Operations

Non-permitted Large CAFO

Non-permitted Medium or Small AFO

Exclusion of livestock from surface water

Required

Required

Required

Discharge Reporting

Required

Required

Required

NDEE Inspection

Required

Required

   Initial inspection required for medium AFOs to determine if permit is needed.    
Small AFOs are exempt.

Livestock Waste Control Facility

Required

Not Required

Not Required

Setbacks away from water during manure application

100 feet or    
35 foot vegetative buffer

100 feet or    
35 foot vegetative buffer

30 feet

State Construction and Operating Permit

Required

Not Required

Not Required

NPDES Permit

Sometimes

Not Required

Not Required

Record Keeping

Required

Recommended

Recommended

Nutrient Management Plan

Required

Recommended

Recommended

Land Application Training

Required

Recommended

Recommended

Annual Report and fee

Required

Not needed

Not needed

 * CAFO determination is based on size, size and location or potential to discharge, or designation by the Director of the Department of Environment and Energy.

Who needs a permit?

The duty to obtain a permit is not based solely on the size of the operation, rather, it is based on the potential for contamination of waters of the State (known as a discharge). Factors that affect risk of discharge include type of housing, management of manure, separation distances and terrain. If there is no risk of discharge, no permit is required, even for large CAFOs. The Nebraska Department of Environment and Energy is responsible for determining if a proposed or existing livestock operation is required to have a permit following an inspection of the livestock facility.

If there is a potential to discharge, a permit will be required. There are two types of permits in Nebraska, a state Construction and Operating Permit and a National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) permit. An operation may be required to have both types.

Nutrient Management Plans

The purpose of a nutrient management plan is to balance nutrient inputs (including both manure and commercial fertilizers) with crop nutrient needs, thus ensuring an adequate supply of nutrients to sustain profitable crop production while minimizing risk of water pollution. Nutrient management plans are tailored to the individual operation, but permitted operations must include the following:

  • Maps and facilities descriptions including types of animals, capacity and how much manure is expected to be produced)
  • Mortality management plan
  • Chemical management plan
  • Descriptions of how the manure/nutrients will be utilized including tentative rates and fields of application
  • Nutrient analyses of soil, manure and irrigation water
  • P-Index
  • Conservation practices in place or expected to be in place to control runoff

Record Keeping

2025 cover of the nutrient management record keeping calendar
Cover of the 2025 Nutrient Management Record Keeping Calendar.

Nutrient Management Record Keeping Calendar is a publication developed by Nebraska Extension through industry sponsorship to make recordkeeping easy and inexpensive for all in the livestock industry.

As referenced in the table above, there are numerous records that a permitted operation must keep, and fewer that others must maintain. Livestock producers are encouraged to develop checklists of items to assist in completing inspections of the production area and manure-related activities and to provide a means of recording the results of those inspections. One such checklist is the Nutrient Management Record Keeping Calendar available from Nebraska Extension. While the calendar includes everything a permitted operation needs related to manure records, it is designed to be used by any livestock operation.

AFOs that have livestock waste control facilities must, at a minimum:

  • Inspect water lines daily
  • Record daily precipitation
  • Inspect the production area and manure storages at least weekly, including stormwater diversions (both clean and contaminated)
  • Inspect irrigation systems used for manure prior to and during use
  • Record manure sludge levels annually
  • Maintain all records for at least 5 years

A guidance document for small and medium AFOs, which explains more about these records, is provided on the NDEE website.

Conclusion

Manure rules can be hard to remember, but always remember your Nebraska Department of Environment and Energy representative is a great resource. Don’t be afraid to call them if you have questions. And, as always, the UNL manure team is here to help if called upon.

Size Classifications for AFOs
Livestock Type     

     Large CAFO     

     Medium AFO     

     Small AFO     

Mature dairy cows

700

200 to 699

less than 200

Veal calves

1,000

300 to 999

less than 300

Beef cattle

1,000

300 to 999

less than 300

Swine ≥55 lbs.

2,500

750 to 2,499

less than 750

Swine

10,000

3,000 to 9,999

less than 3,000

Horses

500

150 to 499

less than 150

Sheep or lambs

10,000

3,000 to 9,999

less than 3,000

Turkeys

55,000

16,500 to 54,999

less than 16,500

Chickens (liquid manure)

30,000

9,000 to 29,999

less than 9,000

Broilers (dry manure)

125,000

   37,500 to 124,999   

   less than 37,500   

Laying hens (dry manure)

82,000

25,000 to 81,999

less than 25,000

Ducks (liquid manure)

5,000

1,500 to 4,999

less than 1,500

Ducks (dry manure)

30,000

10,000 to 29,999

less than 10,000


This article was reviewed by Brad Edeal, Nebraska Department of Environment and Energy. Previously reviewed by Blythe McAfee, NDEE and Rick Koelsch, University of Nebraska